College to review practice of circumcision

News  National Post (Toronto). Friday, 30 August 2002.

Adrian Humphreys


British Columbia College to review practice of circumcision


It was not prompted by baby's death, doctor says

A review of the practice of infant circumcision by the  External link College of Physicians and Surgeons of British Columbia was not prompted by the surprising death last week of a five-week-old baby shortly after undergoing the procedure, the college spokesman says.

The issue was placed on the agenda of the doctors' regulatory board weeks ago, prompted by a sternly worded letter issued by Saskatchewan's college, warning physicians away from performing circumcisions, said Dr. Morris VanAndel, registrar of the B.C. college.

I guess coincidence would be the term for it, said Dr. VanAndel.

Added to the mix now is this particular situation. Whether it will influence the decision, I have no idea.

A five-week-old boy was released from Penticton Regional Hospital after a circumcision on Aug. 20, but his parents went back to talk to the doctor later that day with concerns about bleeding.

The situation worsened overnight, forcing them to rush the child back to hospital early the next day. The infant was flown to  External link B.C. Children's Hospital in Vancouver. He died two days after the procedure.

The death is under investigation by the coroner's office, said Ian McKichan, regional coroner. The college is also investigating the circumstances of the case, said Dr. VanAndel.

An autopsy on the baby was scheduled for yesterday, but the findings were not available.

Rates of circumcision vary across Canada, from a high of 27.6% in Saskatchewan to a low of 0.6% in Newfoundland, according to the Saskatchewan college.

Dr. VanAndel warned, however, against letting emotion over the incident interfere with making a sound policy decision.

Should all decisions be made on an emotional basis because a very tragic and most regrettable complication occurred? Every time somebody dies in a car accident, should we outlaw driving? said Dr. VanAndel.

The  External link College of Physicians and Surgeons of Saskatchewan sent a two-page letter to its members in February, titled Caution Against Routine Circumcision of Newborn Male Infants.

The letter says: It is difficult to identify any other domain of medicine in which physicians would feel comfortable playing such a passive role in a decision pathway culminating in surgery.

It is also difficult to identify any other domain of medicine in which practice patterns stand in such stark contrast to research evidence.

A spokesman for a  External link Canadian anti-circumcision lobby group said the death may serve as a wake-up call for parents who treat the decision to circumcise their babies lightly.

Infant circumcision is not medically necessary except in the rarest of situations. It should be remembered that all surgical procedures have risks, no matter how trivial they may seem at the time, said Arif Bhimji, a Toronto-area emergency room doctor who is a spokesman for the Association for Genital Integrity.

A mounting body of medical evidence suggests the procedure is largely unnecessary and the practice is in decline.

In 1996, the  External link Canadian Pediatric Society published an extensive  External link report in the Canadian Medical Association Journal that concluded, as an official stance, that routine circumcision is not recommended.

Citation:

Back to News 2002 Back to the News 2002 page.


The Circumcision Information and Resource Pages are a not-for-profit educational resource and library. IntactiWiki hosts this website but is not responsible for the content of this site. CIRP makes documents available without charge, for informational purposes only. The contents of this site are not intended to replace the professional medical or legal advice of a licensed practitioner.

Top  © CIRP.org 1996-2024 | Filetree | Please visit our sponsor and host:  External link IntactiWiki.